China celebrated its 20th anniversary of being admitted to the World Trade Organization on Dec. 11. While the mission of the WTO is to ensure that world trade is as smooth, predictable, and free as possible, today’s China remains economically and politically unfree.
As BBC’s economics editor pointed out,
China’s admission to the World Trade Organization changed the game for America, Europe and most of Asia…The promise, suggested by the likes of former US President Bill Clinton, was that “importing one of democracy’s most cherished values, economic freedom,” would enable the world’s most populous nation to follow the path of political freedom too. “When individuals have the power not just to dream, but to realize their dreams, they will demand a greater say,” he said. But that strategy failed.
Pascal Lamy, the European Union trade commissioner at the time of China’s accession and former WTO director-general from 2005 to 2013, stated that China’s accession was a “defining moment” for the WTO and the multilateral trading system, which required China’s “political intelligence, technical knowledge and, of course, a good (accession) team.”
However, he further suggested that, going forward, China needs to do more by fulfilling its “commitment in the WTO.”
To be fair, China’s economic development has been notable since it opened more to the world in the late 1970s and allowed for a more capitalist economic model to succeed.
Entry into the World Trade Organization in 2001 further opened China’s market to foreign trade and investment, enabling China to lift millions more out of abject poverty and give a greater number of Chinese citizens access to a better quality of life and leisure.
Beijing has long taken credit for China’s economic success and wishes to keep it that way.
However, the Chinese Communist Party has never abandoned its socialist ideology and authoritarian approach. Chinese President Xi Jinping has successfully injected the party’s new paradox between craving greater control that puts the party above all and the pursuit of much-needed positive economic outcomes, which has been increasingly challenging.
China has often paid lip service to reforming its bloated, inefficient, state-owned enterprises and command economic structure. Unfortunately, recently announced reforms have rarely panned out, with pro-market reforms slowed and even derailed in some sectors.
According to the Index of Economic Freedom, the Chinese economy remains a mostly unfree country with weak property rights and a protectionist financial system. China’s economic freedom has marginally grown over the past few decades, but at a snail’s pace. The Chinese economy remains “mostly unfree” and stands as the 107th-freest (out of 179) in the 2021 index, lagging behind the majority of other countries in maximizing opportunities for greater economic dynamism.
The Heritage Foundation’s annual “China Transparency Report” underscores:
The U.S. now faces a different China from a decade ago. The emboldened leadership in Beijing has become increasingly aggressive, and in many ways, it is a threat to America, its interests, and its role in the world… With greater transparency on Chinese issues, the U.S. can create policies to keep the [Chinese Communist Party] in check, to neutralize its various threats, and to build a better future for America, for the world, and perhaps even for the Chinese people.
Without any further delay, Washington must better, more realistically understand China’s economy and expose its grave lack of transparency and accountability, particularly as U.S. policymakers and other like-minded partners around the world focus on the challenges China poses more than ever. Countering China’s growing illiberalism must continue to be a priority for Congress and the administration.
This piece originally appeared in The Daily Signal