Why This Dispute in South China Sea Matters to America

COMMENTARY Asia

Why This Dispute in South China Sea Matters to America

Jun 8th, 2021 2 min read

Commentary By

James Di Pane

Policy Analyst, Defense Policy

Alex Jund

Summer 2021 Member of the Young Leaders Program at The Heritage Foundation

Protesters condemn Xi Jin Ping on June 25, 2019 in Makati, Philippines after it was announced that China would continue to fish in the Philippine exclusive economic zone. Jes Aznar / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

How this conflict plays out will have long-lasting effects on the power struggle between China and other nations in the region, and has larger implications.

Although the Philippines have intercepted and driven away its ships, China will not stop its intimidation campaign in the region.

Although the U.S. cannot singlehandedly resolve the complicated dispute in the South China Sea, maintaining that presence will help keep the region open and free.

Tensions between China and the Philippines are rising in the South China Sea. How this conflict plays out will have long-lasting effects on the power struggle between China and other nations in the region, and has larger implications for the U.S. as well.

A total of 220 Chinese militia and fishing boats on March 20 swarmed Whitsun Reef, a coral region in the South China Sea claimed by both China and the Philippines.

Whitsun Reef is situated in the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone. Established in 1982 by the United Nations, exclusive economic zones give countries complete economic control over the area up to 200 nautical miles from their shores, including official rights to drilling and fishing.

In response to China‘s illegally operating its vessels in Philippine waters, the Philippines increased its law enforcement and military presence in the area.

According to the Center for Strategic and International Studies, 13 Philippine military vessels made 57 visits to contested areas from March 1 to May 25. In the previous 10 months, only three Philippine vessels visited these areas a few times.

Although the Philippines have intercepted and driven away its ships, China will not stop its intimidation campaign in the region.

Even though communist Chinese aggression in the South China Sea may seem like a distant problem, the U.S. has a lot at stake economically. Left unchallenged, China’s excessive claims could negatively influence global trade.

China wants to increase its dominance in the South China Sea because it is a major trade conduit where one-third of the world’s shipping occurs. The sea is also rich in seafood and oil reserves.

Because China claims that it owns the majority of the South China Sea, it has infringed upon other Asian countries’ maritime territory. These countries, including the Philippines, have their own exclusive economic zones. They don’t welcome China’s aggressive fishing and patrol vessels, and international courts have ruled against China’s claims.

To overcome the arguments of its opposition, China has relied on gray-zone tactics, which enable countries to achieve security objectives without resorting to violence. These tactics have allowed China to advance its goals peacefully in the South China Sea.

Since 2013, China has been building artificial islands that have turned into military bases in the Spratly and Paracel islands. This bolstered China’s dominance in the South China Sea area compared with other countries. China is gaining the upper hand without firing a shot. 

To counter China’s growing power in the region, the U.S. should continue to support freedom of navigation, which allows ships to move and operate in accord with legal norms, an essential part of global trade and commerce. The U.S. Navy and Air Force conduct Freedom of Navigation Operations that challenge foreign countries’ excessive maritime claims and establish what is appropriate behavior under international law.

Most recently, in February the U.S. carried out a freedom of navigation operation in the South China Sea. Maintaining an American presence there through occasional missions will help decrease China’s presence in the region.

China’s behavior toward the Philippines indicates that it wants to dominate the region through gray-zone tactics. Although the U.S. cannot singlehandedly resolve the complicated dispute in the South China Sea, maintaining that presence will help keep the region open and free, and that will benefit America.

This piece originally appeared in The Daily Signal.