U.S. Needs to Respond to Rising Chinese Influence in the United Nations

COMMENTARY Asia

U.S. Needs to Respond to Rising Chinese Influence in the United Nations

Aug 28th, 2019 2 min read
COMMENTARY BY
Brett D. Schaefer

Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs

Brett D. Schaefer is the Jay Kingham Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs at Heritage's Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom.
This trend is concerning, because China is not a benign force internationally. GREG BAKER / Contributor / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

Chinese influence in the United Nations was rising well before Mr. Trump entered the Oval Office.

As China becomes more powerful economically and militarily, its influence and presence in the United Nations will likewise grow.

Given China’s priorities, the U.S. and like-minded nations cannot neglect the ramifications of this trend.

Chinese influence is on the rise within the United Nations system. Qu Dongyu became director general of the Food and Agriculture Organization this month, raising the number of Chinese nationals leading a U.N. specialized agency to four.

This trend is concerning, because China is not a benign force internationally. It is seeking to shift the values, programs and policies of the U.N. in ways that benefit Chinese priorities and ideology and that undermine the values and practices that have underpinned the international system for decades.

A spate of recent news articles highlighting Chinese influence in the U.N. system commonly attributes Beijing’s ascension to a U.S. “retreat from international leadership” under President Trump. Yet the expansion of Chinese influence in the U.N. system is not a new phenomenon nor is it solely attributable to the current U.S. administration.

The first Chinese national to lead a U.N. specialized agency was Margaret Chan, who took the reins at the World Health Organization (WHO) in 2007. Six years later, Li Yong became director-general of the U.N. Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO). In 2015, Houlin Zhao became secretary-general of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) and Fang Liu became secretary-general of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) in 2015. These last three appointments — all of whom continue to lead their organizations — occurred under President Obama’s watch.

In short, Chinese influence in the United Nations was rising well before Mr. Trump entered the Oval Office. Regardless of why this development is now receiving attention when it did not under the previous administration, it is a legitimate concern deserving notice and response.

As Chinese influence has grown, so has its ability to assert policies at odds with American interests or designed to blunt U.N. mechanisms deemed troublesome or problematic by China.

For instance, China has used its veto to block U.N. Security Council resolutions only 12 times since 1971, when the United Nations recognized the People’s Republic of China as the official government. All but three of those vetoes occurred since 2007. Moreover, those vetoes were cast to protect repressive governments in Burma, Syria, Venezuela, and Zimbabwe from U.N. sanctions and condemnation for their abuses.

Since 2013, China has become increasingly assertive in U.N. human-rights institutions, promoting “its own interpretation of international norms and mechanisms” according to a study by the Brookings Institution. Human Rights Watch has reported Chinese officials intimidating U.N. staff in violation of U.N. rules and harassing non-governmental organizations critical of Chinese policies.

In addition, China expects its nationals working in international organizations to advance Chinese interests and policies, even though international civil servants are supposed to be neutral and independent. In October 2018, China arrested the president of Interpol, Meng Hongwei, and charged him with abuse of power and refusing to “follow party decisions.”

Knowing the potential consequences of not following Beijing’s orders, it’s no wonder Fang Liu has used her leadership position at ICAO to impede Taiwanese efforts to attend ICAO meetings, despite Taiwan being a major air traffic hub.

As China becomes more powerful economically and militarily, its influence and presence in the United Nations will likewise grow. The U.S. cannot reverse this trend entirely, which is based on political and financial realities. Given China’s priorities, however, the U.S. and like-minded nations cannot neglect the ramifications of this trend.

The U.S. must take strategic steps to ensure that Chinese influence is reasonably contained and its leadership restricted and channeled to the parts of the organization that do not directly undermine U.S. interests. This requires a broad, comprehensive, long-term strategy based on a detailed assessment of Chinese interests and tactics, promoting U.S. and like-minded leadership in key international organizations, promoting U.S. employment in international organizations, and applying U.S. pressure purposefully and judiciously.

This piece originally appeared in The Washington Times

Asia

India on the Hill: Charting a Future for Indo-U.S. Relations

Watch live now