Medicare Advantage Needs Reform, Not Cuts

Factsheet Health Care Reform

Medicare Advantage Needs Reform, Not Cuts

March 8, 2024 4 min read Download Report
Robert E. Moffit
Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy
Moffit specializes in health care and entitlement programs, especially Medicare.

Summary

The Biden Administration is proposing cuts to Medicare Advantage, the popular private plan alternative to the outdated traditional Medicare program. These cuts would undermine Medicare Advantage plans and would hurt seniors’ access to higher quality, comprehensive benefits. To prepare the program for the future, Medicare Advantage needs reforms, not cuts.

Key Takeaways

The Biden Administration is proposing cuts to Medicare Advantage (MA), the popular private plan alternative to the outdated traditional Medicare program.

These cuts are an attempt to stop MA’s growth and move seniors back to a one-size-fits-all program that limits their choice of and access to additional benefits.

Instead of cuts, Congress should build on what works and adopt reforms that will strengthen and sustain Medicare Advantage for the future.

The Issue

The Biden Administration is proposing cuts to Medicare Advantage (MA), the popular private plan alternative to the outdated traditional Medicare program. These cuts would undermine Medicare Advantage plans and hurt seniors’ access to higher-quality, comprehensive benefits. To prepare Medicare Advantage for the future, it needs reforms, not cuts.

Biden Medicare Cuts

Growing Popularity of Medicare Advantage

  • Medicare Advantage is the fastest growing part of the Medicare program. Today, over 33 million persons—more than half of all seniors—are enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan, and it is expected that almost 70 percent will be enrolled by 2030.
  • Medicare Advantage gives seniors a wide selection of comprehensive, private coverage options. In 2023, there were 4,000 MA plans nationwide, and Medicare enrollees had on average a choice of 43 plans. Plans are available in all states with several states enrolling more than 50 percent of their Medicare population.
  • The plans’ enrollment represents all income levels, and they are also popular among minorities and those with chronic, complex, and high-cost medical conditions. In 2023, 73 percent of Medicare Advantage enrollees paid no additional premium beyond traditional Medicare premiums and received more comprehensive coverage, including prescription drug coverage, than enrollees in traditional Medicare receive.
  • Unlike traditional Medicare, which does not provide any catastrophic protection, Medicare Advantage plans give seniors financial certainty and security by capping out-of-pocket expenses. In 2023, the average cap was $8,659 for in-network and out-of-network services combined.
  • Medicare Advantage plans outperform traditional Medicare across a number of measures, including more preventive care visits, fewer hospitalizations and emergency department visits, and shorter hospital and out-patient facility stays. During COVID, compared to beneficiaries enrolled in traditional Medicare, Medicare Advantage enrollees had greater access to routine medical care, fewer hospitalizations, and relatively lower mortality rates.

Medicare Advantage Needs Reforms, Not Cuts

  • Instead of trying to stop the growth or get rid of Medicare Advantage, Congress should build on what works and adopt reforms that will strengthen and sustain Medicare Advantage for the future. Congressional and administrative efforts to micromanage these plans will diminish their success and popularity and undermine future innovation in health care delivery.
  • The current Medicare Advantage payment and risk-adjustment model are flawed. Linked to the outdated government-set payment rates, the base payment structure is overly complex, and the current way plans adjust for health risks allows for “gaming” and higher costs at taxpayers’ expense.
  • The benefit package that MA can offer to enrollees is also unnecessarily restricted. For example, Medicare Advantage plans are prohibited from offering hospice care or offering prescription drug coverage with a medical savings account plan.

Strengthening MA by Increasing Personal Choice, Improving Benefits, and Controlling Costs

  • Fix the payment system. The Medicare Advantage payment model should be detached from traditional Medicare and replaced by a competitive, market-based bidding system. It also should update its risk adjustment system with a retrospective payment model to reflect the true costs incurred by the health plan more accurately.
  • Improve benefit options for enrollees. Statutory and regulatory rules limit Medicare Advantage plans’ ability to offer certain benefits. Congress should remove these restrictions to allow plans to develop more innovative options that are tailored to medical needs and conditions.
  • Give seniors better savings options. Today, if a senior chooses a less expensive, more cost-effective treatment, the insurance plan shares in the savings with taxpayers. Congress should allow seniors to share in these savings through premium and copayment rebates that they can pocket directly or deposit tax-free in a health savings account.
  • Make Medicare Advantage plans the default option for seniors. Today, Medicare-eligible seniors are automatically enrolled in traditional Medicare. With the dramatic shift toward Medicare Advantage plans, Congress should make them the default option for enrollment.

Authors

Robert E. Moffit
Robert Moffit

Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy

Exclusive Offers

5 Shocking Cases of Election Fraud

Read real stories of fraudulent ballots, harvesting schemes, and more in this new eBook.

The Heritage Guide to the Constitution

Receive a clause-by-clause analysis of the Constitution with input from more than 100 scholars and legal experts.

The Real Costs of America’s Border Crisis

Learn the facts and help others understand just how bad illegal immigration is for America.