Here’s Why Millennials Are Drawn to Mamdani—and What We Can Do To Change That

COMMENTARY Progressivism

Here’s Why Millennials Are Drawn to Mamdani—and What We Can Do To Change That

Oct 16, 2025 3 min read
COMMENTARY BY
Simon Hankinson

Senior Research Fellow

Simon is a Senior Research Fellow in the Border Security and Immigration Center at The Heritage Foundation.
New York City Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani waves after speaking during a rally in Washington Heights, New York on October 13, 2025. CHARLY TRIBALLEAU / AFP / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

To counter the threat of resurgent socialism at the local and national level, we must understand why he appeals to our young people.

We must first offer a hopeful message by growing the economy, supporting family formation, re-basing education, and restoring fiscal discipline.

More importantly, the federal taxpayer must never assume the debts of the states.

Many Americans outside New York City are wondering why Zohran Mamdani, a young, media-savvy socialist, is the favorite to win the mayoralty of our most iconic metropolis.

It’s easy to ridicule Mamdani and his promises of a socialist utopia. But to counter the threat of resurgent socialism at the local and national level, we must understand why he appeals to our young people.

It’s partially that young people are scared. They’re afraid that the American dream—a good job, a house, financial security, health care, and a secure retirement—is out of reach, so the socialist message of controlled rent, free services, loan forgiveness, and other largesse is beguiling. They don’t really care who’s going to pay for it.

Older Americans realize the problem with this kind of mentality. For us, the argument against communism and socialism is, well, duh. Because we’ve seen it. But for millennials and Gen Z, there is no personal connection.

>>> Philadelphia Plans To Raise the Chinese Flag in a Bizarre Celebration of Communism

Unfortunately, they don’t learn much about it in their history courses either. Not only are they deprived of facts and unlikely to read long textbooks, but the woke curricula used in public schools expose students to much liberal dogma and “critical theory,” instead of just teaching them the dates and facts and how to draw conclusions from them.

To the extent that young Americans relate to the tyrannical regimes of the 20th century, it is to smear their political enemies as “Nazis.” This is, of course, a nonsensical attack.

But it also masks a bleak historical reality. As bad as the Nazis were, they were outdone in sheer scale of offense by the communists. Joseph Stalin starved millions to death with his agricultural and economic policies. His internal political purges killed over a million more Soviet citizens.

In China, Mao’s supposed “Great Leap Forward” into communist utopia during the 1960s killed roughly 30 million people. A few years later, another 1.6 million perished in the Cultural Revolution. Pol Pot slaughtered& two million of Cambodia’s tiny population.

It may be too late for many millennials and members of Gen Z to grasp the lessons of these tragedies. Perhaps the only thing that will teach them that total state control never delivers prosperity and human flourishing is first-hand experience with “true socialism” in action.

But we still must continue the fight against socialism—and we can’t do that on the fumes of the past.

>>> Mamdani Is the Mayor New York Democrats Deserve

To combat the persistent threat of socialism, we must first offer a hopeful message by growing the economy, supporting family formation, re-basing education, and restoring fiscal discipline.

Second, we need to better inform the next generation by returning the school curriculum to basics and stripping it of Marxist theory. We should start by changing “Social Studies” back to History. That’s the proper framing—just teach what happened to K-12 students and leave the theories and ideologies until college or graduate school.

For those lessons to hold, it is essential that states like California, Illinois, and New York don’t bail out their cities for the consequences of socialist policies they voted for. Implemented unchecked, these will most likely reduce the tax base, increase debt, kill economic growth, and end in bankruptcy.

More importantly, the federal taxpayer must never assume the debts of the states. Mamdani wants to spend $100 million on lawyers for illegal immigrants, up to $800 million on free buses, and millions on free child care, subsidized city grocery stores, public housing, and more. Maybe he’ll be able to tax city residents enough to pay for it. If not, it should be New York’s problem, not all of America’s.

This piece originally appeared in the Daily Wire

Heritage Offers

Activate your 2025 Membership

By activating your membership you'll become part of a committed group of fellow patriots who stand for America's Founding principles.

The Heritage Guide to the Constitution

Receive a clause-by-clause analysis of the Constitution with input from more than 100 scholars and legal experts.

American Founders

In this FREE, extensive eBook, you will learn about how our Founders used intellect, prudence, and courage to create the greatest nation in the world.