Middle East Crisis: Can America Protect Americans in the Gulf?

COMMENTARY Middle East

Middle East Crisis: Can America Protect Americans in the Gulf?

Nov 14, 2023 2 min read
COMMENTARY BY
James Jay Carafano

Senior Counselor to the President and E.W. Richardson Fellow

James Jay Carafano is a leading expert in national security and foreign policy challenges.
U.S. President Joe Biden departs the White House in Washington, D.C., on November 1, 2023. JIM WATSON / AFP / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

It is prudent to have capacity in the region to protect and assist all these Americans.

What is really needed from the U.S. is escalation dominance—bold actions that will terrify the Iranians and scare them off.

Biden needs to do a 180-degree policy shift and really start pressuring the regime to fear for its survival.

This is one of those good news/bad news stories.

Here’s the good. The U.S. has deployed two carrier strike groups and a Marine force to the Gulf region. That’s a tremendous amount of very versatile, capable, and lethal power. This is sufficient force to conduct a sustained air campaign and to prevent or respond to attacks on Americans—e.g., the 2012 assault on the U.S. compound in Benghazi, Libya, which left four Americans, including the U.S. ambassador, dead.

The U.S. doesn't have a large footprint in Israel and surrounding countries. Its citizens and diplomatic and military facilities are dispersed throughout the region. Any of these could be targets as Hamas, its supporters, and Iran stir up anti-Americanism as part of their war on Israel. Already, Iranian surrogates have launched dozens of attacks on U.S. military posts in Iraq and Syria—a campaign no doubt orchestrated by the IRGC.

It is prudent to have capacity in the region to protect and assist all these Americans.

>>> Team Biden Let Iran Infiltrate the Nuclear Deal. That Puts All of Us at Risk

Here’s the bad news. Biden isn’t using these forces in the right way at all. His policy is to do the minimum possible to make the threat go away.

First, he basically waved his finger and muttered "don’t, don’t." After repeated attacks by Iranian surrogates on U.S. bases, he authorized a few minimalistic retaliatory strikes—to no effect. The pace of attacks on U.S. bases remains the same. So now Biden says "if" they kill any Americans, the U.S. response will be more severe. The problem is that this allows Tehran to control the pace of escalation. Biden is stuck responding and reacting, always letting Tehran and its minions land the first punch.

What is really needed from the U.S. is escalation dominance—bold actions that will terrify the Iranians and scare them off, like when the last president whacked Qasem Soleimani, the head of the IRGC for orchestrating a campaign of attacks on U.S. forces in Iraq. Biden should level every shack in Syria connected to Iran… like, yesterday.

The U.S. should not only smack a bunch of targets, it should also slip Tehran a target list of people and property that are next. 

Meanwhile, the White House should get cracking on a strategic Plan B for Iran. Engagement is clearly not working. 

Tehran is perilously close to having the capacity to declare nuclear breakout. Indeed, it may already be there. Biden is getting ready to walk into a national election, and if he thinks having a nuclear Iran pop up his watch will help his chances, he needs to guess again.

>>> Biden’s $6 Billion Ransom Payment to Iran Fuels Their Terror Machine

Further, it is more than clear that he can’t bribe the Iranians out of this course. Biden needs to do a 180-degree policy shift and really start pressuring the regime to fear for its survival. If he fails to do this, the mullahs will run all over him. 

Meanwhile, the White House should get cracking on a strategic Plan B for Iran. Engagement is clearly not working.

Tehran is perilously close to having the capacity to declare nuclear breakout. Indeed, it may already be there. Biden is getting ready to walk into a national election, and if he thinks having a nuclear Iran pop up his watch will help his chances, he needs to guess again.

Further, it is more than clear that he can’t bribe the Iranians out of this course. Biden needs to do a 180-degree policy shift and really start pressuring the regime to fear for its survival. If he fails to do this, the mullahs will run all over him. 

This piece originally appeared in Fox News