Common Sense Winning on Fake "Service" Animals in Planes

COMMENTARY Transportation

Common Sense Winning on Fake "Service" Animals in Planes

Jan 25th, 2020 2 min read
COMMENTARY BY
David Ditch

Research Associate, Grover M. Hermann Center for the Federal

David is a budget and transportation associate in the Grover M. Hermann Center for the Federal Budget at The Heritage Foundation.
There is no federal ban. If Delta wants to allow a therapeutic wombat on board, Uncle Sam will not get in the way.  Anadolu Agency / Contributor / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

Trained service dogs, such as seeing-eye dogs, are necessary for the day-to-day life of thousands of Americans.

Since the federal guidelines were not specific enough, some pet owners and medical professionals began to label untrained pets as “emotional support” animals.

The new rule, currently in the public comment phase, would give airlines the option of whether to allow emotional support animals on their planes.

Not many of us want to drive behind “turkeys” on the roads. Even fewer want to sit next to actual turkeys on a flight. Thanks to new action by the Department of Transportation, the public can avoid having planes look like petting zoos.

Trained service dogs, such as seeing-eye dogs, are necessary for the day-to-day life of thousands of Americans. Over the years, canines’ remarkable gifts have extended to assist those afflicted by diabetesneurological problems, mental health conditions, and life-threatening allergies

To accommodate people who require service animals to accompany them at all times, the Department of Transportation has stipulated that airlines must allow them on flights. This caused minimal disruption at first, since properly trained service dogs are extremely well-behaved. 

But since the federal guidelines were not specific enough, some pet owners and medical professionals began to label untrained pets as “emotional support” animals. Airlines hesitated to crack down on these abuses for fear of violating federal statute.

This led to an explosion in the number of animals on flights (1 million in 2018 alone). In addition to all manner of dog breeds, inconsiderate passengers dragged along emotional support cats, miniature horsespigsducksrabbits, and even peacocks

Needless to say, airplanes are not designed for this. Under-trained animals can create problems such as incessant noise and messy defecation. Worse, the conditions of a cramped plane can cause distressed dogs to lash out violently. These incidents have become all too common in recent years.

Thankfully, the Department of Transportation has announced new guidelines for service animals on airplanes that limit the protected service animal category to dogs with specific training to help a person with a medical disability. 

The new rule, currently in the public comment phase, would give airlines the option of whether to allow emotional support animals on their planes.

Unfortunately, sloppy reporting could foment a backlash from pet owners. Mainstream media outlets are spreading misleading headlines. 

From The Washington Post: “Department of Transportation proposes ban on emotional support animals on planes.” From The New York Times: “U.S. Plan Would Ban All Service Animals From Planes Except Dogs.” From Bloomberg News: “The U.S. Department of Transportation proposed a ban on emotional support animals.”

There is no federal ban. If Delta wants to allow a therapeutic wombat on board, Uncle Sam will not get in the way. 

If some airlines crack down, others can market themselves as pet-friendly. Rather than using the federal government to force airlines to allow these animals on board, we should trust airlines and passengers to find what works best through the marketplace. 

That’s exactly what the new rule seeks to accomplish, and both two-legged and four-legged Americans will be better off for it.

This piece originally appeared in The Daily Signal