Has AI ruined education? Not in Florida.
Within proper bounds, AI holds promise in education and industry. But the OECD’s latest international results should sober anyone who thinks chatbots can stand in for thinking.
U.S. students still lag their peers in other developed nations. Students who used AI more than their classmates did worse at summarizing information and doing research. The share of “hasty readers”—kids who race through a passage and miss what it actually says—nearly doubled between 2018 and 2025. That is what happens when a generation raised on social media meets machines that do the hard work for them.
But Florida is not pretending the technology away. Florida is putting it in its place.
This month the State Board of Education approved rules that run from pre-K through the Florida College System. Districts and charter boards will have to write AI into their internet-safety policies. Parents get notice when a teacher approves a tool, and they get a real alternative if they opt out.
>>> American Schools Cost More Than Ever but Our Students Still Keep Failing
Extra scrutiny applies in the early grades. Student data cannot be sold or used to train commercial models. AI may not pose as a companion, score a child’s personality, or replace a teacher’s judgment. Colleges must set clear rules on integrity, assignments, and grading.
The point is simple: approved use should protect records and still serve achievement, civic literacy, academic excellence, and workforce readiness.
Rules are not a curriculum. They only work if classrooms still demand reading, reasoning, and memory.
Florida’s Civics Literacy Excellence Initiative, launched in 2021, raised the bar for teachers and students. Florida is among the states that require both a civics course and a passing score on a civics assessment before graduation. Some states still require neither. State colleges and universities accept the Classical Learning Test, which pulls from enduring literature and philosophy and uses mathematics to test logic. As workforce needs change, students need to adapt and digest dense material, weigh evidence, and decide—not outsource the thinking.
High standards fail if families cannot choose where their children meet them. That is the second half of Florida’s story.
A generation ago, public education mostly meant a zip-code assignment. Today the state funds the student and lets the family pick the setting. More than half of Florida’s publicly funded students now learn somewhere other than their zoned school: charters, scholarship-supported private schools, home education, and district schools of choice.
Districts did not wither. They competed.
>>> Florida Continues to Take Top Spot in Heritage’s 2026 Education Freedom Report Card
Families choose district-run options more than any other category. Miami-Dade alone built more than 100 magnet schools, some ranked among the best in the country. Teachers and principals became entrepreneurs instead of waiting for permission.
The results are not theoretical. In 1998, Florida’s graduation rate sat just above 50 percent. Today the statewide rate—including the rate for black students—is around 90 percent. That is not the abandonment of public education. It is public education answering to students and parents.
That mix of content, transparency, and parental power is why Florida ranks first on The Heritage Foundation’s Education Freedom Report Card for the fifth consecutive year. The scorecard does not grade states on how much they spend. It asks whether families have real options, whether parents can see what is taught, whether skilled adults can enter the classroom to be educators, whether spending produces results, and whether civics is taken seriously.
AI is here. Florida’s job is to keep it a tool—not a substitute for reading, judgment, or independent thought.
Guardrails, rigorous instruction, and genuine choice are how Florida sends students into the world ready to think for themselves.
This piece originally appeared in RealClear Education