America’s National Pastime: Remembering the Role of Women

COMMENTARY Civil Society

America’s National Pastime: Remembering the Role of Women

Mar 31st, 2020 3 min read
COMMENTARY BY
Angela Sailor

Vice President, The Feulner Institute

Angela serves as Vice President of The Feulner Institute at The Heritage Foundation.
Three young female baseball players around 1910. Transcendental Graphics / Contributor / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

In 1898, Lizzie Arlington became the first woman to be signed by a professional men’s baseball league.

It is worth remembering that women have worked for over a century to carve a place for themselves in the great American pastime.

That’s an all-American attitude—the same attitude that will enable us to overcome COVID-19, return to normalcy, and once again hear the words, “Play ball!"

COVID-19 continues to alter day-to-day life in America. For example, Major League Baseball’s opening day games were slated for last Thursday. But the ballparks remain shut indefinitely. When they’ll reopen is anybody’s guess.

Twenty-five years ago, the baseball news was more upbeat. On March 31, 1995, Major League Baseball players agreed to end a 232-day strike that had kept fans shut out for 938 games—including the 1994 World Series. 

In the absence of any live games to watch today—and with Women’s History Month drawing rapidly to a close—let’s look back at some of the pioneering women who proved that America’s pastime isn’t just “a man’s game.”

In 1898, Lizzie Arlington became the first woman to be signed by a professional men’s baseball league. After playing in exhibition games for several months, she was called up by the Reading Coal Heavers and, on July 5, became the first woman to play for a men’s pro team, pitching a scoreless ninth inning to preserve the win against the Allentown Peanuts. 

While Arlington was proving she could hold her own on the men’s field, a former teammate of hers was proving a woman could make her way up baseball’s corporate ladder. 

Maud Nelson began her professional career at the tender age of 16, pitching for the Boston Bloomer Girls. In 1911, the 29-year-old Nelson became owner-manager of the Western Bloomer Girls and a professional scout, recruiting players for both men’s and women’s professional teams. She worked in the sport for two more decades before retiring.

On April 2, 1931, 17-year-old Jackie Mitchell went to the mound for the Chattanooga Lookouts, a Double-A men’s team, in an exhibition game against the New York Yankees. She proceeded to do the seemingly impossible: She struck out Babe Ruth. Smithsonian Magazine recounts the story this way:

First up was Ruth, who tipped his hat at the girl on the mound ‘and assumed an easy batting stance,’ a reporter wrote. Mitchell went into her motion, winding her left arm ‘as if she were turning a coffee grinder.’ Then, with a side-armed delivery, she threw her trademark sinker (a pitch known then as ‘the drop’). Ruth let it pass for a ball. At Mitchell’s second offering, Ruth ‘swung and missed the ball by a foot.’ He missed the next one, too, and asked the umpire to inspect the ball. Then, with the count 1-2, Ruth watched as Mitchell’s pitch caught the outside corner for a called strike three. Flinging his bat down in disgust, he retreated to the dugout.

Mitchell wasn’t through, though. The next batter she faced was Lou Gehrig. She struck him out, too. 

The fans ate it up, but Major League Baseball Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis had seen enough. He revoked Mitchell’s contract with the Lookouts, claiming the sport was “too strenuous” for women. Tell it to the Babe!

Thankfully, not everyone in Major League Baseball was down on women in sport, and when World War II broke out, they got another chance.

During the war years, more than 2,000 minor league players traded in their team jerseys for military uniforms. As a result, many of the teams folded. 

Trying to fill the void—and the nonrevenue-producing stadium seats—Philip K. Wrigley, owner of the Chicago Cubs, organized the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League, later immortalized in the film “A League of Their Own.” 

Wrigley’s gambit worked—for the owners, the players, and the fans. According to the women’s Players’ Association, the typical game attracted 2,000-3,000 fans a game. In 1946, an Independence Day double-header in South Bend, Indiana, drew a crowd estimated at 10,000.

The All-American Girls league folded in 1954, but women have continued to break barriers and achieve success in the game. 

In 1989, NBC’s Gayle Gardner became the first woman to regularly host Major League Baseball games for network television. 

More recently, Jessica Mendoza, a six-year veteran of the U.S. women’s national softball team, become the first female commentator to work an MLB postseason game and the first to serve as a World Series game analyst on national radio.

As Women’s History Month draws to a close with Americans deprived of baseball for the first time in a quarter-century, it is worth remembering that women have worked for over a century to carve a place for themselves in the great American pastime. And they have succeeded, through a combination of grit, talent, and determination. 

That’s an all-American attitude—the same attitude that will enable us to overcome COVID-19, return to normalcy, and once again hear those beautiful words, “Play ball!”

This piece originally appeared in The Daily Signal