Paul Ryan Offers a Budget for Grown-Ups

COMMENTARY Budget and Spending

Paul Ryan Offers a Budget for Grown-Ups

Apr 6th, 2011 2 min read

Former Distinguished Fellow

Ernest served as a Distinguished Fellow at the Heritage Foundation.
House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan, R-Wis., has proposed a budget for grown-ups.

Washington’s big spenders have responded with the tired clichés we expect from defenders of big government:
  • "Pulling the rug out from under seniors,” says Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich.
  • “Waging war on American workers,” says Rep. Xavier Becerra, D-Calif.
  • “A path to poverty for America’s seniors and children,” claims House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif.
  • "The tea party has hijacked the Republican caucus," says House Budget Committee Ranking Member Chris Van Hollen, D-Md.
Pee Wee Herman could have delivered more creative comebacks. But adult conversation about serious issues is lacking in Washington, D.C.

Ryan’s plan should be rated at least R for Realism while the dismissive comments are PG for Politically Guided.

Ryan’s plan is a big deal. A very big deal. Its proposed $6.2 trillion of savings (compared to Obama’s budget) over 10 years is literally 100 times larger than the $61 billion that the GOP is trying to cut this year — and that Democrats are fighting against ferociously.

Changing Medicare to a defined contribution plan is a good course to pursue, and of course a tough sell. But it makes a huge difference in controlling spending and reducing deficits. The same with revising Medicaid to give states flexibility to deliver care more efficiently — yet with limited federal outlays.

As The Heritage Foundation’s annual Index of Dependency notes, dependence on government is skyrocketing. Ryan would address that.

Spending limitations, rollbacks, and freezes. Repeal of Obamacare. Cutting corporate welfare (including farm subsidies) as well as overly generous giveaways to individuals. Structural reform for federal healthcare programs, which are the biggest runaway spending items.

Ryan’s plan gets serious in a way nobody else has.

But his “Path to Prosperity” is about economic growth, not just spending. Tax simplification is one aspect, and so is lowering corporate taxes so businesses are not pushed overseas by what is now the world’s highest rate. A Heritage Foundation analysis finds this would create a million jobs a year for starters, and double that rate in short order.

It’s not perfect. Our national defense needs are greater than Ryan projects. Social Security’s problems are not addressed. And welfare reform should go beyond what he lays out.

But Ryan’s proposal is good, tough stuff — strong medicine that we need, not politically correct placebos that the plan’s opponents are already peddling.

We live in a time when cute sound bites substitute for debate and false claims are used to justify inaction despite our fiscal crisis. While most of his critics carp without offering any alternative, Ryan has delivered a needed challenge before we fall totally over the fiscal cliff.

Paul Ryan respects Americans — especially taxpayers. He speaks to us like adults. For the rest of Washington, it’s time to put away childish things.

Ernest Istook, a distinguished fellow at The Heritage Foundation.

First appeared in Newsmax