With Inflation Raging, Congress Must End Spending Spree

COMMENTARY Budget and Spending

With Inflation Raging, Congress Must End Spending Spree

Nov 22nd, 2021 4 min read
COMMENTARY BY
David Ditch

Policy Analyst, Grover M. Hermann Center for the Federal

David is a policy analyst in the Grover M. Hermann Center for the Federal Budget at The Heritage Foundation.
U.S. President Joe Biden walks on the South Lawn after a Marine One arrival at the White House November 19, 2021 in Washington, D.C. Alex Wong / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

A poll conducted by the Pew Research Center found that 93% of Americans are concerned or very concerned about inflation.

It appears that all too many members of Congress don’t share that concern about inflation.

The latest version of the "Build Back Better" bill contains over $2 trillion in spending and tax credits, and would add hundreds of billions to the debt.

If you’re worried about the direction of the nation, the state of the economy, or the sharp rise of price inflation, you’re not alone.

A recent Associated Press poll found 65% of Americans say economic conditions are poor, and a poll conducted by the Pew Research Center found that 93% of Americans are concerned or very concerned about inflation.

Sadly, it appears that all too many members of Congress don’t share that concern about inflation.

Inflation, a problem we associate with the dismal 1970s, has indeed come roaring back over the last year. Economy-wide prices have increased much faster than wage or economic growth, eating into household budgets.

>>> 9 Examples That Show Why Democrats’ Revised Spending Bill Is Still Awful

In an environment where American families must be careful with their finances, it would make sense for legislators in Washington to do the same for the nation’s finances. Yet we have seen just the opposite.

Congress has passed four major spending bills since the start of the pandemic and added a staggering $5.5 trillion to the national debt in the process. That’s about $43,000 in new debt for every household in the country.

Much of that spending has been wasteful or opportunistic, such as bailouts for politically connected industries and unnecessary handouts to state governments.

Pushing so much extra money into the economy over such a short period of time certainly helped contribute to today’s high inflation. With more dollars chasing the same number of goods, prices were bound to increase.

Amazingly, Washington’s spending spree shows no sign of slowing down.

On Monday, President Biden signed a $1.2 trillion infrastructure spending package into law. Nonpartisan analysts have shown that the bill will add hundreds of billions of dollars to the debt, even after the use of budget gimmicks such as repurposing stimulus funds that weren’t going to be used.

Worse, much of the infrastructure spending will go to waste. For example, it heavily funds modes of transportation such as mass transit and Amtrak that only a small percentage of the country uses. This is happening at a time when trends like remote work and teleconferencing threaten to make transit and intercity rail even more irrelevant.

Coming on the heels of the $1.9 trillion “American Rescue Plan” from March, the infrastructure bill ought to be enough to satisfy even the biggest spenders on Capitol Hill.

It appears they’re just getting warmed up.

Biden’s massive spending package labeled “Build Back Better” is being furiously debated in both the House and Senate. The latest version of the bill contains over $2 trillion in spending and tax credits, and would add hundreds of billions to the debt.

More importantly, that cost is severely understated due to a heavy dose of gimmicks.

According to the nonpartisan Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, the real cost of the bill is closer to $5 trillion. That’s because many key programs in the bill are only put in place for a short period, in some cases as little as a single year.

Since taxes in the bill are spread over 10 years, while the spending is front-loaded, the effect would be an enormous deficit increase at a time when the economy is already wracked by the biggest inflation spike in decades.

The White House has sought to deflect this criticism with threadbare talking points. One of these flimsy rebuttals is that the bill has “zero cost” if it doesn’t add to the debt.

Setting aside that it would indeed add to the debt, this would be like emptying your retirement account to buy a Corvette and then claiming the car didn’t cost anything because you paid for it.

>>> Congress’ Wasteful Spending Spree Must End With Infrastructure Bill

More tellingly, administration officials have claimed that the bill wouldn’t worsen inflation as long as it doesn’t add to the debt.

However, what matters for today’s inflation isn’t whether the bill balances over a decade, but whether it balances over the next few years. Since it uses massive deficit spending to artificially pump more money into the economy, that will put pressure on prices to increase even faster than they already are.

Federal finances were already in rough shape before the pandemic. Both parties have long ignored the problems facing major benefit programs like Social Security and Medicare, which are heading towards bankruptcy in the near future.

Rather than making inflation worse by creating new programs that are already bankrupt in advance, Congress should recognize the importance of responsible governance and start to live within their means.

That’s what American families have to do every day. Washington shouldn’t get a pass just because they have the privilege of using other people’s money.

This piece originally appeared in the Detroit News