Trade and Prosperity in the States: The Case of Wisconsin

Report Trade

Trade and Prosperity in the States: The Case of Wisconsin

August 30, 2017 9 min read Download Report
Tori K. Whiting
Research Associate
Tori helps to write, edit, and promote Heritage’s premier annual publication, the Index of Economic Freedom, as a research associate.

Summary

Businesses in Wisconsin exported $21 billion in goods in 2016. More than 8,000 businesses, employing nearly 119,000 Wisconsinites, export goods to countries around the world each year. In 2014, 90,000 Wisconsinites owed their jobs to foreign direct investment, representing 3.7 percent of all private-sector employment in the state. Access to competitively priced intermediate goods is crucial for manufacturers in Wisconsin. In 2016, Wisconsin’s goods imports were valued at $22.4 billion, including intermediate goods like engine parts, wood pulp, static convertors, and tube fittings. Wisconsin’s congressional delegation should encourage the Trump Administration to make eliminating additional U.S. and foreign tariff and non-tariff barriers the main priorities in any impending negotiations.

Key Takeaways

Wisconsin businesses exported $21.0 billion in goods in 2016, employing nearly 119,000 people.

In 2014, 90,000 Wisconsinites owed their jobs to foreign direct investment, representing 3.7 percent of all private-sector employment in the state.

Access to competitively priced intermediate goods is crucial for Wisconsin manufacturers. In 2016, Wisconsin’s goods imports were valued at $22.4 billion.

International trade and investment supports one in five private-sector jobs in Wisconsin. The state’s manufacturers depend on competitively priced intermediate goods, sourced domestically and internationally, to produce finished goods.

Wisconsin’s elected officials demonstrated in their last free trade agreement (FTA) votes that trade is a vital aspect of the state’s economy. Both Senators and all but two Representatives voted in favor of the free trade agreements with South Korea and Panama. Wisconsin’s elected officials should continue to strongly support free trade.

While trade agreements can effectively and efficiently lower or even eliminate tariffs or non-tariff barriers for all countries involved, they are not the only mechanisms available to make it easier for Wisconsin businesses to compete in the global economy. Wisconsin’s elected officials should support elimination of tariffs on imports that are used as inputs, because they are self-destructive measures that only make end goods more expensive for consumers.

Exports Support Wisconsin Jobs

Businesses in Wisconsin exported $21 billion in goods in 2016. More than 8,000 businesses, employing nearly 119,000 Wisconsinites, export goods to countries around the world each year. Of these exporting companies, 87 percent are small or medium-sized.[REF] Wisconsin service exports grew by 77 percent between 2006 and 2015 to $6.2 billion, supporting more than 46,000 jobs.[REF]

Machinery, computer and electronic products, transportation equipment, chemicals, and processed foods are the top five export industries in Wisconsin. More than 19 percent of all goods exports from the state were in the machinery category in 2016, valued at just over $4 billion. Goods exports from the four other categories were valued at $1.9 billion (processed foods), $2 billion (chemicals), $2.3 billion (transportation equipment), and $2.9 billion (computer and electronic products).[REF]

Wisconsin's Leading Exports in 2016

America’s North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) partners, Canada and Mexico, are Wisconsin’s top export markets, consuming $6.6 billion and $3.1 billion, respectively, in U.S. goods in 2016. China, Japan, and the U.K. complete the state’s top five export markets. More than half of all exports from Wisconsin go to America’s 20 free trade partners.[REF]

Wisconsin Ranks Eighth in Manufacturing Output

Manufacturing is a robust and prominent industry in Wisconsin. The state was ranked eighth in 2016 in terms of manufacturing output as a percentage of gross state product, amounting to 18.2 percent.[REF] In 2016, 94 percent of Wisconsin’s total exports were manufactured goods, an increase of nearly 7 percent since 2010.[REF]

Manufacturing Output Rankings

More than 460,000 Wisconsinites are employed in the manufacturing industry each year.[REF] Employment in the industry is largely driven by small businesses, which provide 46 percent of all manufacturing jobs.[REF] Nearly 50 percent of Wisconsin jobs supported by foreign direct investment are in the manufacturing sector.[REF]

Removing Tariffs on Intermediate Goods

More than 60 percent of goods imported in the U.S. each year are considered intermediate goods, components used to make final goods or capital goods like machinery.[REF] Access to competitively priced intermediate goods, regardless of origin, is crucial for manufacturers in Wisconsin. In 2016, Wisconsin’s goods imports were valued at $22.4 billion. Intermediate goods like engine parts, wood pulp, static convertors, and tube fittings are among the state’s top 25 import categories.[REF]

Between 2013 and 2016, American manufacturers paid an estimated additional $748 million in tariffs that would have been eliminated by a miscellaneous tariff bill (MTB), according to the National Association of Manufacturers.[REF] The cost of tariffs on all inputs is much higher. Bryan Riley, senior policy analyst at The Heritage Foundation, states that “[p]ermanently eliminating tariffs on inputs is a trade policy that would be guaranteed to encourage more job-creating investment in the U.S.”[REF] Congress has allowed for temporary tariff cuts in the past, through MTBs and other measures. To effect lasting benefits for American businesses, Congress should allow permanent cuts.

Foreign Direct Investment Creates Jobs

Foreign investment is a crucial piece of free trade. Millions of Americans each year are employed by foreign companies that decide to invest in America. In 2014, 90,000 Wisconsinites owed their jobs to foreign direct investment, representing 3.7 percent of all private-sector employment in the state and 9.5 percent of manufacturing employment.[REF]

Wisconsin’s Top Five Sources of Foreign Investment Jobs

In 2017, German candymaker Haribo announced plans to build its first U.S. plant in Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin. Haribo will invest $242 million in the project and the facility will eventually support 400 jobs, a huge boon for this small Midwestern village.[REF]

Alpla Inc., Europe’s largest plastic-packaging producer, will establish a new manufacturing plant in West Bend, Wisconsin. With 14 plants already established in the U.S., Alpla supports approximately 1,200 jobs in the U.S., a number set to increase with this newest project. According to Tom Jablonsky, vice president of manufacturing for Alpla in North America, the company plans “to grow employees internally and add locally as much as possible.”[REF]

All Wisconsin Businesses Deserve Competitive Tax Rates

Wisconsin currently has a variety of tax credit programs that lower corporate tax rates for manufacturing and agriculture businesses to nearly zero, while the overall corporate tax rate is 7.9 percent. While decreasing corporate tax rates does help businesses grow, doing so through temporary or selective programs is essentially another form of government favoritism.[REF]

Wisconsin’s corporate tax rate is high compared to other Midwest states, such as Michigan and Indiana, which have rates of 6 percent and 6.25 percent, respectively. Lowering the corporate rate to a more regionally competitive rate for all Wisconsin businesses would benefit the state’s overall economy, and not just certain industries.[REF]

Support for Free Trade Among Wisconsin Legislators

Support for free trade by Wisconsin’s congressional delegation has been inconsistent since the passage of NAFTA in 1993. However, in 2011, six of eight Representatives from Wisconsin voted in favor of the FTAs with Colombia, Panama, and South Korea. Both of the state’s Senators supported the agreements with Panama and South Korea.[REF]

How Wisconsin Voted on Trade Agreements

While a handful of Wisconsin Representatives and Senators have stood their ground in supporting free trade over the years, Members will be put to the test as the Trump Administration seeks to renegotiate existing trade agreements and pursue new ones. Wisconsin’s congressional delegation should encourage the Administration to make eliminating additional U.S. and foreign tariff and non-tariff barriers the main priorities in any impending negotiations.

Free Trade Is Vital for Wisconsin

The ability to freely buy and sell goods is crucial to Wisconsin’s economy. The state has robust manufacturing and agriculture sectors that not only export products around the world, but also rely on inputs from those countries. As the Trump Administration prepares to renegotiate NAFTA and seek agreements with other countries, Wisconsin’s elected officials should support policies that lower barriers both at home and abroad. Such policies will allow Wisconsin businesses to compete and prosper in the global economy.

—Tori K. Whiting is Research Associate in the Center for Free Markets and Regulatory Reform, of the Institute for Economic Freedom, at The Heritage Foundation.

Authors

Tori K. Whiting
Tori Whiting

Research Associate

Terrorism

Defeating Terrorism in the Age of Trump

Watch live now