March 31, 2006 | WebMemo on Immigration
The disparity between job growth in
America and in other countries has contributed to the recent influx
of migrants into the United States, such that between 10 and 12
million illegal aliens now reside in the United States. According
to a Pew Hispanic Center study and the U.S. Census Bureau, more
than half are from Mexico.
Success in reducing this tide requires
better border security, workplace enforcement, a practical
guest-worker process to match prospective workers with legitimate
employment, and encouragement for labor-exporting nations to reform
their laws and economies to provide avenues of social mobility now
absent in their societies.
In Mexico's case, the good news is that
sound fiscal policies, the North American Free Trade Agreement
(NAFTA), and institutional reforms have kept lots of workers at
home. The bad news is that job growth has not been fast enough to
keep pace with new entrants into the labor force.
Mexico's Interior Secretary Carlos Abascal
Carranza visited Washington recently with a progress report. That
alone is a welcome change from what Americans have heard for the
last five years from President Vicente Fox-that Mexico should have
the right to export its surplus workers to the United
Fox's first Foreign Secretary pushed that absurd message without regard to America's sovereignty or Americans' sensitivities. No country exists to take on the problems of others. On the other hand, all nations dwell in an increasingly interdependent world, and internal problems can have consequences that extend across borders. So it should come as no shock that the U.S. has a strong interest in Mexico's economic policies and performance.
Speaking at The Heritage Foundation on
March 23, Secretary Abascal reported that Mexico's economy has, in
fact, grown stronger under President Fox and poverty levels are
Click here to view Secretary Abascal's PowerPoint
presentation.) For instance, from 2000 to 2005:
Still, nearly a million youths enter the
Mexican labor force each year. A half million new jobs per year are
simply not enough. Mexico's minimum wage is US$4.50 per day, far
below the minimum US$5.15 per hour stateside. While more Mexican
children are attending school, the system is still heavily
centralized under an inefficient national ministry and subject to
nationwide strikes. Rural facilities and attendance are
Other net labor exporters in our hemisphere are worse off. Guatemala and Honduras report poverty rates close to 75 percent. In South America's Andean ridge-from Venezuela to Bolivia-the poor constitute more than half of the population. Except in Colombia, a developing trend is to consolidate power within plenipotentiary presidencies, ignore the rule of law, over-regulate small business, and let the state to set prices and salaries.
Not surprisingly, Ecuadorians are showing up in shipping containers in Costa Rica while Peruvians are choosing the United States as a base for new businesses. One of Venezuela's most popular websites continues to be www.MeQuieroIr.com ("I Want to Leave").
Migration is a hot topic in Washington,
with Congress debating whether to tighten border security, which
some consider the silver bullet solution to curbing flows, and
whether it should be easier for temporary workers to obtain legal
employment through labor and visa reforms.
While these two approaches are necessary, they are not enough to slow economic migrants. In daily relations, public diplomacy, and development policies toward Latin America, the U.S. government must do a better job of urging hemispheric neighbors to liberalize economies, untangle and cut burdensome business regulations, and ensure equal treatment of all citizens under the law to spread prosperity more broadly.
Mexico has already gone partway under Fox, but it must continue these efforts to account for the needs of its expanding population. Candidates running for the Mexican presidency and congress this year should hear from U.S. officials that backsliding toward populism will limit economic opportunities for their own workers and create friction between our two nations.
According to the U.S. Conference of Mayors, many U.S. cities' annual economic output rivals those of entire foreign countries. There is no reason that resource-rich countries like Mexico and others in Latin America cannot approach such prosperity. To ease the tide of unauthorized migrants, U.S. foreign policy must seek to balance the equation.
Stephen Johnson is Senior Policy Analyst in the Douglas and Sarah Allison Center for Foreign Policy of the Kathryn and Shelby Cullom Davis Institute for International Studies at The Heritage Foundation.