After watching elections in the Southern hemisphere produce a
disheartening turn towards socialist populism, it was encouraging
to see a win for Conservatives in Canada in Monday's elections. The
result could be a far more civil tone in the U.S.- Canadian
relationship and more international cooperation. This is good
news.
The election victory of Canada's Conservative Party under the
leadership of 46 year-old economist Stephen Harper will bring an
end to12 years' of Liberal rule. Or perhaps one should say, "help
bring an end," for the government of Prime Minister Paul Martin had
not only run out of steam, but also got entangled in a major
kick-back scandal, which brought it down in a vote of no-confidence
in November. In this week's election, the Conservatives came away
with 36.4 percent of the vote to the Liberals 31.3. Like the
Liberals before them, therefore, the Conservatives will constitute
a minority government, which of course, does not mean an altogether
easy road ahead.
Unsurprisingly, Canadian media has tried to paint Mr. Harper as a
dangerous extremist. Is there any conservative who is not, in the
media's view? He has been accused of wanted to stop regional
development, tamper with social security, restrict immigration, and
open up capitol punishment and abortion to a national referendum.
And then there is the issue of same-sex marriage, which is now
legal in Canada, on which Mr. Harper has been suspected of wanting
to turn back the clock.
The reality, however, is that Canada's Conservative leader emerged
in this election as a fiscal, tax-cutting conservative, but more of
a liberal on social issues. He has pledged not to touch abortion,
and proposed a parliamentary vote on homosexual marriages. He
favors a ban on handguns, and the creation of a national childcare
program. This is by no stretch of the imagination a conservative
radical.
As far as foreign policy became an issue in the election, it was
Prime Minister Paul Martin who reached for the last refuge of
Canadian politicians, anti-Americanism. As former Prime Mister Jean
Chretian once commented, "I like to stand up to Americans. It's
popular." Mr. Martin even got into a spat with the U.S. Ambassador
to Canada, David Wilkins over the Kyoto Treaty, a subject on which
Mr. Martin accused the United States of lacking a "global
conscience." He persistently told Canadians that he would stand up
to President Bush - unlike Mr. Harper. But as in the recent German
elections, anti-Americanism wasn't enough to swing the vote this
time.
While Mr. Harper has taken pains to emphasize that he will take an
independent stance from the United States, there is reason to
believe that his government will place fence mending high on their
list of priorities. An apt comparison might be the changing tone of
the U.S.-German relationship under newly elected Christian Democrat
Chancellor Angela Merkel, who by her recent visit to Washington
showed an early commitment to overcome the discord characterized
U.S.-German relations under her Social Democratic
predecessor.
Mr. Harper would do well to consider the success of Mrs. Merkel's
January visit to Washington, and make a similarly early gesture of
reaching out to the Bush administration to repair relations. He
has, for instance, promised to reconsider Canadian support for U.S.
missile defense, which would be a practically cost-free gesture,
seeing as the United States is not actually asking Canada to
contribute any physical assets. Mr. Harper has also pledged to
increase Canadian defense spending and with it Canada's
contribution to NATO. On Homeland Security, where cooperation has
generally been good, Mr. Martin has talked about further tightening
security on the U.S.-Canadian border.
Canada should not be expected to add troops to Iraq, but an
increased profile in Afghanistan and Haiti are on the table. Canada
already has a sizable contingent of so Mr. Harper has proposed
moving beyond the stalled Kyoto debate by looking at different sets
of environmental controls. While he is promising to be a tough
negotiator on trade issues, such as Canadian lumber, Mr. Harper has
also pledged to take a leading role in negotiating the Free Trade
Area of the Americas.
In other words, while getting our hopes up for a major warming
trend in U.S.-Canadian relations might be too early, at least
today, the atmospherics from the North look more promising than
they have in a long time.
Helle
Dale is director of the Douglas and
Sarah Allison Center for Foreign Policy Studies at the Heritage
Foundation.