Even with the economic recovery underway, state lawmakers
nationwide are finding it tough to balance their budgets. As a
result, many have been lobbying for - you guessed it - higher
taxes.
They haven't made much headway in Arkansas, though. Gov. Mike
Huckabee has refused to sign off on tax hikes, provoking howls of
protest from those who warn of cutbacks in "vital" state
programs.
Gov. Huckabee prefers to do what real-world people do when faced
with tight budgets: Cut spending. (It's not as if the average
citizen has the option of taxing someone when it looks as if he or
she won't make this month's mortgage payment.)
But the governor doesn't want to stand in the way of those who
want to pay more. "There's nothing in the law that prohibits those
who believe they aren't paying enough in taxes from writing a check
to the state of Arkansas," he said.
So in December, Gov. Huckabee created the "Tax Me More Fund," so
people who consider themselves undertaxed can donate more to the
state government.
Sounds reasonable. Surely those who derided the governor for his
opposition to tax hikes would open their wallets for the sake of
the "vital" programs they hold dear.
That's the theory, anyway. But things have worked out
differently: At last report, the fund had raised about $1,900.
The Arkansas story illustrates what we already know: We're not
undertaxed. In fact, we're overtaxed. And it costs us: According to
the National Taxpayers Union (NTU), Americans shell out an average
of 35 to 40 percent of their earnings each year in taxes. A
relentless array of federal, state and local taxes chip away at our
paychecks, while sales taxes and registration fees siphon off even
more. The mortgage, utilities, food, etc., come out of what's
left.
Most financial planners say it's smart to create a "rainy day"
fund equivalent to six-months' worth of expenses. But most people
have little disposable income after the government takes its share,
so saving that much money could take years. Meanwhile, the car
needs new tires. The washing machine breaks down. The roof starts
leaking.
Now, it's clear that Gov. Huckabee didn't expect his "Tax Me
More Fund" to do more than highlight the hypocrisy so prevalent
among the tax-hiking elite. It seems that was the goal in Kansas,
too, where state legislators opposed to Gov. Bill Graves' plan to
raise taxes -- rather than cut unnecessary spending -- set up a
"Tax Me More Fund," too.
It's an attractive idea. Lawmakers in Arizona, California,
Massachusetts and Virginia also have considered creating "Tax Me
More" funds. We encourage more.
The lesson these funds teach is simple: Americans don't want to
pay more taxes. An NTU poll found that, by a margin of 63 percent
to 26 percent, Americans prefer to accelerate the tax-rate
reductions President Bush signed last year-or enact additional
cuts.
But tax-hikers don't see it that way. While most families and
individuals peg their spending to their income, tax-hikers do the
opposite. They figure out how much they want to spend and then find
creative new ways to gouge it out of us. It stems from a flawed
belief that taxpayers exist to serve government.
Deep down, though, most Americans understand that it's really
the other way around. Otherwise, Little Rock's "Tax Me More Fund"
would be overflowing.
Edwin
Feulner is president of The Heritage Foundation, a
Washington-based public policy research institute.