REGULATION IN BRIEF:
Overtime Exemptions
(More Resources)
February 18, 2004 No. 9
(Updated September 29, 2004)
Background: On April 23, 2004, the Department of Labor (DOL) issued final, new rules for determining whether or not an employee qualified as an executive, administrative, or professional employee, and was therefore exempted from the Fair Labor Standards Act overtime rules and other requirements. These rules took effect August 23rd. The prior rules for these “white-collar” exemptions were considered to be outdated, and confusion over their application has led to large lawsuits against employers.
Status: Organized labor has opposed the new rules, and both houses of Congress have approved amendments that would block the new regulations. The administration has indicated it is likely to veto any such legislation.
Discussion: The Fair Labor Standards Act, originally passed in 1938, establishes forty hours as the standard workweek and provides employees with “time-and-a-half” pay for hours worked over the standard forty. The FLSA provides for exemptions, and just who qualifies as a “white-collar” employee is a critical question for both employers and employees. But many of the prior rules that determine who qualifies date back to the 1950s and are in need of an update.
Salary levels that employees must receive in order to be considered executives, administrators, or professionals, had not been updated since 1975. Depending on job duties, an employee might have been considered exempt while earning as little as $155 per week.
The prior rules also attempt to evaluate the nature of the work being performed, but in practice this part of the rules has proved to be very difficult to apply. Finally, the current rules do not account for the rise of highly skilled and highly compensated production workers.
Confusion over application of the exemptions has lead to private legal judgments as high as $90 million against employers who have misinterpreted the rules, not always in bad faith.
The new rules will increase the minimum salary an employer will need to pay before a worker can be considered “exempt” from $155 to $455 a week. At the same time, the rules were streamlined, making it easier for workers, employers, and investigators to determine whether or not an employee should be eligible for overtime pay.
Clarifying and updating the rules will also allow private employers to make more common-sense decisions regarding which employees will and will not be eligible for overtime, lessening the risk of private lawsuits based on FLSA. Finally, by increasing minimum salaries required for exemptions to apply, the proposed regulations will guarantee that low-wage workers receive overtime, bringing enforcement more in line with the intent of the act.
Action item: Congress should allow the new regulations to take effect without interference . Congress may consider mandating more frequent revisions to the white-collar rules in order to keep these important regulations current.
This brief was prepared by Heritage Visiting Fellow Paul Kersey.
The "Regulation In Brief" is produced regularly by The Heritage Foundation, providing concise summaries of key regulatory issues, along with links to key background material on each issue. If you wish to be removed from the "Regulation In Brief" mailing list, please e-mail Margaret Hamlin at Margaret.Hamlin@heritage.org.
Regulation In Brief Library
Return to RegWatch
