Why would the most powerful economy in the world leave so much
of its own energy sources untapped?
Alone among countries, the United States has placed a
substantial amount of its oil and natural gas potential off limits.
Other countries drill just off our shores. But U.S. firms face
restrictions on drilling in most offshore areas, even as American
drivers face sharply higher prices at the gas pump.
Congress seems poised to do something about this policy by taking
up the Deep Ocean Energy Resources (DOER) Act of 2006. And it's
about time.
Domestic oil and gas production has failed to keep pace with
growing demand, but it's not because we're lacking for domestic
energy. Since the 1990s, the federal government has placed severe
restrictions on new energy development, particularly in some of our
most promising areas.
But back then, oil and natural gas were cheap, and the need for
additional energy wasn't considered significant. Also, the 1989
Exxon Valdez oil tanker spill led to heightened environmental
concerns about offshore energy production.
Environmental concerns took precedence over future economic
considerations. Soon, access to 85 percent of federally controlled
offshore areas had been restricted, including the Pacific and
Atlantic coasts, and portions of the areas off the shores of Alaska
and the eastern Gulf of Mexico. No one knows how much energy lies
in these areas. But many agree there's enough to bring stability to
energy markets and make a real difference in oil and natural gas
prices for years to come.
According to a recent Interior Department study, restricted
offshore areas contain an estimated 19 billion barrels of oil and
84 trillion cubic feet of gas - several years' worth of total U.S.
consumption. It may be even higher given that most of the
off-limits areas haven't been thoroughly explored.
Moreover, the central and western Gulf of Mexico - the only
offshore areas where drilling is permitted - were dealt severe
blows last year by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. At the peak of
damage, one-fourth of America's domestic oil and gas production was
off-line. No offshore wells suffered significant spills resulting
from the storms.
Politics, not geology, is the reason America has put so many
energy eggs in this one hurricane-prone basket. Those storms should
teach us that allowing drilling elsewhere (and related refining and
pipeline infrastructure) would give us greater supplies, lower
prices and less vulnerability should disaster strike any one
area.
Our policies need to catch up with the times. Oil and natural gas
prices have tripled since the 1990s. Demand continues to increase,
by a steady 1.5 percent per year. Imports have increased. Political
stability in oil-producing nations has decreased. Domestic
production has flattened, even as our ability to extract resources
without environmental damage has increased dramatically.
Today, scientists estimate that merely 1 percent of the oil found
in U.S. waters results from oil production spills.
Cuba wants to let the Chinese drill in some of the very parts of
the gulf that American producers are forbidden to touch, some as
close as 45 miles off the Florida coast. Do we truly believe the
environmental safeguards of Chinese energy firms are better than
ours?
It's time we stop assuming that all energy exploration is bad.
Most takes place too far from the coast to be seen, and we haven't
had a spill from offshore drilling in nearly 40 years. Neither has
Canada, which permits drilling off its Atlantic and Pacific coasts
and in the Great Lakes, where some rigs are closer to U.S. shores
than American producers are permitted to drill.
The DOER Act is intended to overcome state opposition to offshore
energy production. It would empower the governments of coastal
states to decide whether to permit offshore oil and natural gas
production. States that want to keep the federal restrictions could
do so; those that want to permit drilling could also do so. Only
drilling in waters more than 100 miles from the coast would be
outside state control.
States that permit drilling would receive a share of the leasing
and royalty revenues. Currently, all revenues from offshore
drilling go the federal government, even though states and the
federal government split the royalty proceeds from onshore energy
production.
America's energy problems are partially self-imposed, and that
needs to end. Congress overreacted in the 1990s, and it needs to
undo its damage. Our need for affordable energy will not decrease,
and the time has come to lift the restrictions on offshore energy
production and let U.S. producers do what they can to meet our
growing energy needs.
Ben
Lieberman is a senior policy analyst at The Heritage Foundation
(heritage.org), a Washington-based public policy research
institute.
First appeared in the Baltimore Sun